GRP BoatS Impact on Marine Environments

The use of Glass Reinforced Plastic (GRP) in seafaring craft began in the early 20th century and surged in popularity during the 1960s. According to Rubino et al. (2020), nearly 80% of ship hulls under 20 meters in length are now made of GRP. In the UK alone, the number of recreational boats owned by households was estimated at 1.2 million in 2019 (Statista.com), although the Royal Yachting Association (RYA) estimates the figure is closer to 5 million when including kayaks and paddleboards. The revenue from building sporting and pleasure boats in the UK is projected at 4.8 billion USD (Statista.com).

While GRP's popularity has grown across industries, composite waste management remains a global challenge. Landfill remains the most cost-effective disposal method for composite waste, with efforts to use bio-derived products or recycle GRP hindered by high costs and the lack of established standards (IMO Report, 2019).

A 2019 report for the International Maritime Organization (IMO) estimated that six million fiberglass boats exist in the European Union. Of these, over 100,000 GRP boats reach the end of their useful life annually, with only 2,000 recycled and 6,000–9,000 abandoned (IMO Report, 2019). This leaves approximately 90,000 to 100,000 boats unaccounted for each year, likely abandoned and leaching harmful chemicals into the environment.

The disposal crisis is particularly acute for island nations, where landfill space is scarce (Mohee et al., 2015). Efforts are underway to explore solutions such as pyrolysis, chemical breakdown, and mechanical disintegration, as well as to prevent at-sea disposal (scuttling) and onshore burning (Lemieux et al., 2004). Abandoned vessels pose significant risks to sensitive habitats such as reefs, seagrasses, and estuarine intertidal zones (Lord-Boring et al., 2004), as well as to human health and safety (Turner & Rees, 2016). Additionally, a growing social crisis looms as abandoned boats, particularly in areas with rising housing costs, are being used as temporary shelters by homeless individuals.

University of Brighton (2021)

Conchological Society of Great Britain and Ireland (2023)


The Science

Scientists from the University of Brighton, University of Portsmouth, and other institutions conducted a groundbreaking study along the south coast of England, examining oysters and mussels near active boatyards. Led by Dr. Corina Ciocan, the team used advanced techniques to detect significant amounts of fiberglass particles in the tissues of these filter-feeding shellfish. They found up to 11,220 particles per kilogram of wet tissue in oysters and 2,740 particles per kilogram in mussels, highlighting the alarming extent of contamination.

Seasonal Spikes and Accumulation
The study revealed that contamination levels spiked during winter, coinciding with heightened boat maintenance activities such as sanding and cutting of GRP boats, identified as major sources of fiberglass pollution. The particles were found primarily in the digestive glands of oysters and mussels, which are essential for processing nutrients.

Impact on Marine Life
Fiberglass ingestion poses a severe risk to marine bivalves like oysters and mussels. As filter feeders, they accumulate these particles, impairing their feeding, growth, and reproduction. Laboratory studies confirm that prolonged exposure can harm their health, reduce populations, and disrupt marine ecosystems.

A small water snail pierced several times, looking like a floating pin cushion. Copyright: Corina Ciocan.

A bundle of fibreglass, 10 times thinner than human hair. Copyright: Corina Ciocan.

Ciocan’s magnified sample of fiberglass pollutants shows a combination of resin and glass. Copyright: Corina Ciocan.

Resin and glass surround and spear a water snail and water flea in a sample collected by Ciocan and her research team. Copyright: Corina Ciocan.


Dr. Corina Ciocan and University of Brighton

Dr. Corina Ciocan, a Marine Biologist Professor at the University of Brighton, leads groundbreaking research into one of the coastal environment's most pressing challenges: the legacy fleet of GRP boats. These aging vessels, often abandoned and deteriorating, release microplastics, fiberglass, antifouling chemicals, and other harmful substances into the environment (Ciocan et al., 2020).

Corina’s team is using innovative technologies to provide a comprehensive macroscale analysis of the “abandoned fleet” along the South Coast of England and its environmental impacts. The researchers aim to deliver a deeper understanding of the fate and effects of end-of-life GRP boats, laying the groundwork for new legislation to minimize their environmental and economic impacts.

To address potential conflicts between legislative goals and socio-economic realities, the team collaborates with local and international partners. This integrated approach not only advances sustainability in the boatbuilding industry but also sets a benchmark for addressing critical environmental challenges in the 21st century.


Articles

Research Papers

Release of a “forever material” from end-of-life boats and glass-reinforced composite boats is pervasive and entering food chains

Science Behind the News, 25 September 2024, Corina Ciocan, Kethan Jha, Claude Annels, Rachel Kozloski, Ilse Steyl, Simon Bray

Building boats of sufficient strength and durability to withstand the harsh water environment has always been a challenge. Composites, particularly glass-reinforced plastic (GRP), historically provided one of the best low maintenance solutions. Over the past 80 years, GRP boats have become a mainstay of the boating industry while little attention has been given to the consequences of GRP degradation, lack of recycling solutions, and boat abandonment. This paper highlights the widespread glass fiber pollution and alarming levels of glass microparticles entering aquatic food chains. Prospective legal and policy measures are, therefore, required to manage risks to human and marine life…

 

Glass reinforced plastic (GRP) boats and the impact on coastal environment – Evidence of fibreglass ingestion by marine bivalves from natural populations

Journal of Hazardous Materials, July 5 2024, Corina Ciocan, Claude Annels, Megan Fitzpatrick, Fay Couceiro, Ilse Steyl, Simon Bray

Classified as marine debris, man made materials are polluting the world’s oceans. Recently, glass reinforced plastic (GRP) has been shown to degrade and contaminate the coasts. In this pioneering study, fibreglass particles have been detected in the soft parts of oysters and mussels collected from natural populations, in front of an active boatyard. The presence of particulate glass, with concentrations up to 11,220 particles/kg ww in Ostrea edulis and 2740 particles/kg ww in Mytilus edulis, was confirmed by micro Raman spectroscopy. The results showed higher accumulation during the winter months, when boat maintenance activities are peaking and, through repair work, the release of glass fibres in the environment is more likely. Bivalves are considered high risk species due to their sessile nature and extensive filter feeding behaviour. The microparticle inclusion may contribute to adverse impacts on physiological processes and eventually to a decline in the overall health and subsequent death of the animal. The high costs involved in the proper GRP disposal and the lack of recycling facilities worldwide lead to boat abandonement and further contamination of the coasts. For the first time this study presents the extensive fibreglass contamination of natural bivalve populations, in a popular South England sailing harbour, designated a biological and geological site of specific scientific interest (SSRI)…

 

Media

A Brief Modern History of Fiberglass

Practical Sailor, and, Voyage Virage Substack, November 15 2024, Angie Richard

Fiberglass, also known as glass-reinforced plastic (GRP), has been an integral material in modern engineering and design, especially within the marine industry. Its lightweight, durable, corrosion, and marine organism-resistant properties have made it a favored choice for boatbuilders since the mid-20th century. But what of its origins?
In my own search to understand how fiberglass swept the world by storm, I set out to trace the material’s historical development, technical composition, and ‘revolutionizing’ impact on the marine industry, particularly in recreational and competitive sailing.

 

What Do You Do With Old Fiberglass Boats?

Pratical Sailor, and, Voyage Virage Substack, September 19 2024, Angie Richard

Despite a presumption that fiberglass is a hazardous material (it’s not officially classified as one, yet…), the thought of a huge boat refit, which would require us to spend months or even years dealing with fiberglass, was daunting, and we declined Jac’s offer without hesitation. It was only recently that research revealed the shocking impacts of GRP on marine environments and its potential entry into our food chain…

 

Boat fiberglass is making its way into shellfish: study

Cape And Islands, August 29 2024, Gilda Geist

Glass-reinforced plastic, or GRP, is a composite material used in millions of recreational boats around the world. The problem is, there's no way to recycle it. A new study in the Journal of Hazardous Materials found that shellfish are ingesting large amounts of fiberglass, predominantly coming from these GRP boats. CAI's Gilda Geist spoke to the lead investigator on this study, ecotoxicologist Corina Ciocan, of the University of Brighton, to learn more about what the results of her study mean for shellfish populations…

 

Sur les littoraux, les épaves de bateaux entraînent une pollution difficile à enrayer

Le Monde, August 22 2024, Lucile Coppalle

Recouverte de mousse verte, la carcasse gît depuis plusieurs années à Beg Melen, une crique que les habitants de Plouguiel, dans les Côtes-d’Armor, aiment appeler leur « petit port ». Ce canot d’environ 5 mètres de long, un misainier, a perdu depuis longtemps sa voile. Des algues semblent avoir remplacé les cordes d’amarrage qui retiennent la barque. Le métal est rouillé par le sel de mer. Construit dans l’ancien chantier naval de la commune, fermé au début des années 2000, le canot est échoué dans la vase, tout près de son lieu de fabrication…

 

Fiberglass classified as hazardous?

Voyage Virage Substack, July 23 2024, Angie Richard

In a time of much division across Europe and the world, it was a joy to come together at the University of Brighton for the GRP Symposium ‘Bridging the Gap Between Science and Policy – End of Life Boats,’ organized by Dr. Corina Ciocan. The event brought together a diverse group of scientists, academics, end-of-life boat management stakeholders, boat builders, students, concerned citizens, and boating authorities, as we gathered to share knowledge and exchange dialogue about Corina’s recent research, which reveals the shocking impact of fiberglass on marine life such as oysters and mussels…

 

水辺に不法な「放置船」ズラ~リ…一体誰の?規制どうなってる? 全国5.6万隻、愛好家注目の珍しい船も

TOKYO Web, July 22 2024, 岸本拓也

全国の河川や港湾に放置されたプレジャーボートなどの小型船が思うように減っていない。国は2022年度までに「放置船ゼロ」目標を掲げたものの、いまだに5万隻以上が不法に係留されている。水辺の景観を損ね、自然災害で流されて被害を拡大させるリスクもはらむ放置船。不法係留の現場を歩きつつ、現状の課題と対策を考えた。

 

Environmental cleanup removes derelict boats from Dee Estuary

Wrexham News, July 14 2024

A number of derelict boats have been cleared from the Dee Estuary as part of an effort by Natural Resources Wales (NRW) officers to remove potentially hazardous materials from the environment. The clean-up is a crucial part of NRW’s Marine Litter and Derelict Vessel Prevention Project aimed at restoring the health of the Dee Estuary. By removing these derelict boats and debris, NRW says it is supporting the ongoing work to protect the “delicate ecosystem that supports a diverse range of wildlife in the area.”

 

Fibreglass particles from boats found in oysters and mussels - Marine Business

Marine Business News, July 4 2023, Katrina Read

A new study by researchers at Brighton and Portsmouth universities has revealed worrying levels of fibreglass in oysters and mussels. The study marks the first-time fibreglass or glass reinforced plastic (GRP) particles have been found entering the food chain raising environmental and health concerns. GRP particles were detected in the soft tissues of oysters and mussels collected near an active boatyard in Chichester Harbour on the south coast of England…

 

British study reveals ‘disturbing level’ of fibreglass in oysters and mussels

Marine Industry News, July 3 2024, Anna Cummins

A new study has revealed worrying levels of fibreglass in oysters and mussels in British waters. The research authors say it’s the first time fibreglass or glass-reinforced plastic (GRP) particles have been found entering the food chain, raising urgent environmental and health concerns…

 

The Shocking Impact of Glass Reinforced Plastic (GRP) Boats on Coastal Environments

Voyage Virage, May 15 2024, Angie Richard

Fiberglass particles are infiltrating our coastal waters, primarily through the maintenance and abandonment of GRP boats. When these boats are repaired, abandoned, or broken down, tiny fiberglass particles are released into the environment. Over time, as boats age and degrade, they continue to shed these harmful particles into the water…

 

Les bateaux abandonnés, une menace pour les eaux canadiennes

Radio Canada, March 9 2024, Camille Vernet

Dans les eaux canadiennes, près de 1500 bateaux délaissés se détériorent, menaçant les écosystèmes marins. Conscient du problème, le gouvernement fédéral peine à se débarrasser de ces embarcations abandonnées, ce qui suscite de l'inquiétude et de l’impatience au sein des communautés côtières….

 

Chloe McCardel leads environmental effort after Channel Queen wreckage

On The Wight, August 2 2023, Chloe McCardel

Following the recent loss of the 54ft Trader Sunliner motor yacht, ‘Channel Queen’ off the Isle of Wight, Chloe McCardel, the vessel owner, crew from the vessel, a group of concerned locals, and others from the South of the UK are rallying together to salvage the debris from the wrecked ship ‘Channel Queen’. United by their concern about the debris and chemicals left behind to wreak havoc on the local environment. They will conduct beach cleans from 1,30pm Thursday 3rd August at Freshwater Bay and Compton Chine, Isle of Wight. The Channel Queen vessel was reinvented as a commercial vessel and children’s classroom for teaching sustainability by Chloe McCardel and her partner Roy Beal…

 

The Problem with Boating’s High-Fiberglass Diet

Haikai Magazine, July 11 2023, Norman Miller

Fiberglass revolutionized boating, but decades later, discarded and degraded vessels are adding to marine pollution. We can do something about it…

 

Brighton research on microplastic marine pollution raises primetime alarm

University of Brighton, September 7 2022

Research by University of Brighton on an overlooked cause of potentially health-damaging marine pollution has been highlighted on BBC1's The One Show…